Cuts will hit families hard
The Daily News (Prince Rupert)
June 29, 2007
Opinion & Letters -- The Coalition of Child Care Advocates of BC

An open letter to Minister Linda Reid:

Dear Minister Reid,

July 1, 2007, the day on which your government will cut Child Care Operating Funds (CCOF) for licenced family and group child care programs across B.C. is upon us. We are hearing from our community across B.C. about families facing impossible choices, caregivers despairing after years of dedicated service and organizations unable to yet again find a way to make do.

There are no organizational reserves or cost savings to cover the loss of CCOF The child care community is already under-funded and reeling from years of instability. The sector is in the midst of a human resource crisis as current wages are too low to recruit and maintain quality early childhood educators.

So, as advised by you, child care fees across B.C. are going up. For infant/toddler care, increases of $75 a month are needed just to cover CCOF cuts let alone improve wages or meet other escalating operating costs. Total monthly fees for children under three could now be over $1,000. More families will have no choice but to remove their children from licenced care and scramble to find alternatives. Other families will have to leave the labour force or reduce their working hours deepening B.C.'s growing labour shortage and ongoing concerns about family poverty. Children, families and the whole community will pay the cost for years to come.

While you claim to be concerned about the most vulnerable families, you seem blind to the fact that all families will have to pay higher fees. Families who receive a provincial child care subsidy to help cover child care costs, most of whom already pay for the difference between the subsidy they receive and the actual cost of care, will have to cover fee increases out of their own pockets just like everyone else.

Again, you rationalize this away by saying that families should use the taxable family allowance they receive from the federal government to pay higher child care fees. Yet, other early learning programs that you fund, including Family Resource Programs and the new Strong Start programs where parents must attend with their children are free. Even though all families get the federal allowance, only working families who need child care are being punished by your government.

As devastating as these realities are for individual families and communities, the real tragedy is that the July 1 cuts to CCOF are totally unnecessary.

You blame the cuts on the loss of dedicated federal child care transfer payments saying that you had no choice but to spend $95 million in remaining federal child care funds on one-time-only grants rather than ongoing funding for CCOF. But B.C.'s outgoing Acting Auditor General and the current Comptroller General have both publicly confirmed that the province has the ability to make decisions about child care spending this year and beyond. It is revealing that B.C. is the only province to cut ongoing child care funds while engaging in a flurry of unaccountable year-end spending in response to the reduction in dedicated federal funds.

And, even without federal funds, B.C. has the money it needs to sustain CCOF. B.C.'s expected surplus for 2006/07 is $3 billion. All that's lacking is the political will to allocate a mere $15 million to at least maintain current CCOF levels let alone begin to build the child care system B.C. needs.

We know that you have heard these arguments before from thousands of British Colombians. To date, you have not listened. On behalf of the children, families, child care providers and communities of B.C., the Coalition of Child Care Advocates of B.C. is making one last call to reason. Act now to stop the cuts or expect to be held accountable.